Dual pricing
Now, who doesn’t love a bargain? Although perhaps we should immediately define a bargain – something bought or offered for sale much more cheaply than is usual or expected, BUT performs as well as the dearer one!
Ihave a wonderful in-law who simply cannot resist a bargain. That dress reduced from £150 to £50 was, clearly, a bargain. However, the fact that she was not looking for one, had nowhere to go in it, and had three wardrobes full of other bargains, made me feel that maybe it was more a case of spending £50 when she could have spent nothing.
Another member of the family is Shropshire’s biggest fan of Primani – the nickname for the bargain clothes retailer where half the items are on the shop floor by 11am. Perhaps one of the leading proponents of ‘disposable clothing’ – so cheap it really doesn’t matter if you only get to wear it once, she manages to look after the stuff and make it last.
My weakness is probably dining out or events. Watching City beat Everton 5-0 in May with a brace by Aguero made the tickets a bargain, but watching a turgid 0-0 draw with Southampton was a disgraceful rip-off …
And so to the nightmare of every bargain-hunter – that pair of golf shoes you bought with a £25 Member Scheme January Sale Discount now have a £50 whoever-you-are February Sale Discount. How could they be so cruel and unscrupulous? ‘Infamy, infamy, they’ve got it infamy’.
Bringing me to the most annoying pricing of all. Who is more important to anyone – the person you’ve known for a while, or the person you’ve just met? Who is the more important customer – the one who comes in regularly or the new one? In business both can apply – there are those that offer discounts to get new members on board, and there are those that apply discounts for continued loyalty.
In our industry dual pricing has long been the bane of our lives – the same insurer offering a cheaper price for new business compared to renewal for the same product to people with the same rating factors.
For example, in car insurance rating factors such as age, experience, location, profession, type of car etc. can be identical yet produce a different price for new as opposed to renewal.
Thankfully, after years of our team having to check the two prices and ensure we offer the best, the Financial Conduct Authority are clamping down on insurers to make sure the prices are the same, with new rules being implemented in January.
It will be interesting to see how the comparison sites cope. In the meantime, we’ll continue to check, every renewal, that the rates we are given match.
Have a good November.•
by Mark Freeman
Henshalls Insurance Brokers




