Friday, November 20 2026

Now many of you may have seen the news story a week or so ago about the court case involving the daughter who, after preparing a homemade will without any legal intervention, filmed herself getting her terminally ill mother in the end stages of dementia, to sign a ‘will’ disinheriting her son and leaving her entire estate to her daughter, physically manipulating Mum’s hand to put a mark on the will.
Thankfully justice prevailed and after an £80,000 legal battle, the judge ruled the will was invalid and the fallback position, under an intestacy, of an equal division between children was the correct one. I thought today I ought to point out some of the pitfalls of a homemade will as I still have the odd client who knows someone who has prepared their own will, and I cringe inside waiting to see if anything goes wrong down the road!
A will is a crucial document that ensures assets are distributed according to an individual’s wishes after they die. While the idea of creating a homemade will may seem appealing due to simplicity and cost-effectiveness, it carries significant risks that can lead to serious complications for both the individual and their heirs. Here are some of the dangers of a homemade will and why seeking professional legal assistance is the best choice.
1. Lack of legal validity
One of the most significant risks of a homemade will is that it may not meet the legal requirements to be considered valid. Very specific rules exist governing how a will must be executed. Including requirements such as the testator (making the will) being of sound mind, the will being written voluntarily, and being signed by the testator in the presence of two witnesses who are not mentioned in the will. If any of these elements are missed or improperly executed, the will may be invalid, leaving the estate to be distributed against the deceased’s wishes.
2. Ambiguities and misunderstandings
A homemade will is typically drafted without legal expertise, which can lead to ambiguity or unclear instructions. When the terms of a will are not clearly defined, it opens the door for disputes. Vague phrases like ‘I leave everything to my children’ can be interpreted in multiple ways, leading to disagreements and challenges. A solicitor can ensure that the will is written in precise, clear language, reducing the likelihood of confusion and conflict.
3. Missing important legal provisions
It may overlook critical provisions necessary for effective estate planning. Issues such as guardianship, handling digital assets, and tax considerations may not be addressed in a simple DIY will. Certain assets, such as jointly owned property or life insurance policies, may not be included or properly allocated. A solicitor specialising in estate planning can ensure that all relevant factors are considered minimising the potential for costly mistakes.
4. Potential for fraud or coercion
They may be more susceptible to fraud or undue influence. Because homemade wills are often drafted without professional oversight, such as this recent case, they are easier to manipulate, either by altering the document after it is signed or by pressuring the testator into making changes they don’t truly want. Lawyers can help ensure that the will is drafted in a way that protects against coercion and minimises the opportunity for fraud.
5. Family disputes
Family members may not always agree with the contents of a will, if there is no legal professional involved, it may lead to disputes that drag on for years. A homemade will, lacking the assurance of legal guidance, can make it easier for family members to contest validity. A lawyer can help provide a more reliable and professional structure to minimise the chances of disputes, ensuring wishes are carried out smoothly and fairly.

While a homemade will might seem like a cost-effective solution, it can create significant problems in the future. Clarkes have a whole department dedicated to contentious probate matters; it’s a growing industry! To avoid problems, it is essential to seek professional legal assistance when drafting your will. Clarkes will help ensure that your will is legally sound, clear, and comprehensive, protecting your legacy and providing peace of mind for both you and your loved ones. Contact Rachel Davenport on 01952 281060 to make sure your will is legally correct and does what you want it to.

by Rachel Davenport
Clarkes Solicitors

Previous

Mantovani

Next

Toyota Yaris CR Hybrid

Check Also