Friday, November 20 2026

“Everyone is a genius but if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree it will live its life thinking it is stupid”. The jury might be out on whether this popular quote, attributed to Einstein was ever actually said by the great man but it still makes a really valuable point.

Our education system is all too often geared towards a narrow set of tests with a very narrow set of results that fail to account for children’s progress at different stages, their different talents, and the potential negative impact of having one chance to prove what they have learned during years of hard work. I think most of us would agree it’s far from an ideal system of encouraging learning or even truly knowing what our children are capable of achieving.
Standard Assessment Tests or SATs, based on the National Curriculum, are a case in point. I’m sure most parents and a lot of year six children get the chills just thinking of the SATs mill and all the added anxiety it can cause at a crucial stage of a child’s schooling. The tests, carried out in year six as children prepare for what is a big landmark in their education with the transition to secondary school, can prove a highly stressful time for families.
The suggestion is these tests provide a much-needed measurement of where children are at before they join a new school. But I have talked to many headteachers at senior schools who have said the lack of SATs last year, as schools were closed during the pandemic, made very little difference to a successful transition and a child’s education continuing seamlessly.
Certainly what did help was a primary or prep school which had taken the time to really get to know the child’s strengths and abilities and their rate of progress with different types of learning at different stages.
Rather than cold hard scores, a detailed reference from their headteacher was much more crucial, informative, and insightful.
Now to be clear, I am not against assessments, as that is partly how a school gets to know a child and also how they can measure progress and give parents valuable information on how their child is doing. We can only look at improving on whatever is happening by recognising where things are going right and where they are going wrong.
We just prefer not to do SATs or any kind of endgame exams here at Old Hall School in year six. We much prefer a more progressive and pastorally-sensitive method of measuring how they are getting on throughout their journey with assessments as part of their usual school work twice a year from year three.
The children take it in their stride as part of the everyday rather than a perceived one-off chance to be at their best in a very specific set of exams. It also provides us with evidence-based data to show parents how their children are progressing and discuss next stage steps in more detail.
I do feel sad sometimes when I see a child’s last year at primary school ruined by the worry over SATs – no 10 or 11-year-old should feel this kind of pressure.
Assessments should really be a tool for the teacher to look at how that child is doing and how they are learning so they can spot a need for change or extra support as early as possible. Should they need a lake rather than a tree, for example, to thrive and encourage that inner confidence in their abilities then it is our job to discover that and create that environment for them.
It’s the quickest route to a child being happy and engaged at school and therefore more likely to reach their full potential.

by Martin Stott, Headmaster at Old Hall School

Previous

Everyday tips to ease anxiety

Next

Pat Boone

Check Also