Friday, November 20 2026

We had a large fir tree blow down in our garden during the very strong winds in the middle of November. Since then, we have been on the trail of the lonesome pine to replace it. Have you seen the Laurel & Hardy film ‘Big Business’ when they are trying to sell Christmas trees to residents who clearly do not want to buy them, especially one grumpy fellow? I went to see a one-man show at the Stafford Gatehouse, (other theatres are available), with a very old friend of mine, which was on those two eternally funny men. We were shown a clip from the aforesaid film. Outside one of the houses, there was a sign which said, ‘No Solicitors’. This tickled my pal, Neville.
My title comes from the nickname of Rugby player Billy Twelvetrees. I am sure you will soon work this one out, armed with the knowledge that the then captain of the Tigers was one Geordan Murphy. Billy T is currently plying his trade with Worcester Warriors. He formerly played for Gloucester and, prior to that, Leicester Tigers.
When our aforementioned tree came crashing down, I got in touch with the ever-dependable David Bowsher. He does such a good job and is a lovely fellow to boot. I thought there would be three fellas, but in fact, there were only two of them.
One always has to be very careful with trees and branches overhanging a neighbour’s garden, or protruding into the stratosphere. I was in Waitrose in Newport just after New Year. I went to the till to buy a paper. Her Indoors, who had ventured outdoors on this occasion, said it was noticeable, as she was waiting, that the vast majority of people picked up a Daily Mail as their reading material of choice (other papers etc.). Stories of 30-foot-high conifers blocking out light and causing neighbour disputes seem to often feature in the aforesaid newspaper. Many houses, particularly those on a development, do not have an inherent right to light. However, it is clearly not good to have overly high trees, especially Leylandii, or some other fast-growing specimen. I am reminded of the Lord Denning case from 1947, which all law students must study as a rite of passage, which became known as the ‘High Trees Case’. In this case, the doctrine of promissory estoppel took root. This principle prevents a party from backing out of a promise that the other party has relied on, even though this promise was not supported by consideration (money).
I will finish this month with these words from Woody Allen: “Of all the wonders of nature, a tree in summer is perhaps the most remarkable; with the possible exception of a moose singing ‘Embraceable You’ in spats.”
by David Wassell
david@middletonlaw.co.uk
of Middleton Law

Previous

Get ready for Renters' Rights

Next

Choosing a bed that minimises partner disturbance

Check Also