Friday, November 20 2026

In the UK we have a rather bizarre relationship with insurance. Unlike anything else, we seem to buy it purely based on price. Brand, customer experience and recommendations lose out in our rush to get it as cheap as possible.

In any other area of our lives this approach is not seen. We buy certain phones based on their branding and customer experience – despite being more expensive than the competition in most cases. We buy cars mainly on brand name, even where one brand shares the same chassis and parts of another, yet the more popular brand will still be the one we buy despite being more expensive.

So why do we have such a different view of the world when it comes to insurance? Is it a product of the comparison website? Or is the industry itself to blame, with much of the advertising being price based?

This drive to get the very lowest premiums on any given policy has a number of drawbacks for the consumer; the lack of brand being a differentiator means that fraudsters can easily set-up bogus companies and pretend to be an insurer, stealing thousands of pounds and then disappearing. It also means that to compete insurers have had to come up with ways of making their policies cheaper, generally by reducing the levels of protection in their policies.

This then brings us on to the next part of the jigsaw. How often do we hear people say “insurance companies never pay out”? It’s an often stated remark when insurance is discussed; but with most people’s experience of insurance being around home, car, or travel is this surprising if they are bought on the basis of finding the very cheapest they can?

We don’t seem to give insurance products the same degree of grace that we do with other purchases. If we bought the very cheapest car we could find, when it broke down we’d say “well, what did I expect? It only cost £XXX”. Yet we don’t say the same when we try and claim on the cheap policy we found online. It seems to be a unique dilemma of insurance products – we expect the cheapest ones to behave in exactly the same way as the premium ones.

Over my many years dealing in insurance contracts of various types one truth has held firm – if you pay the bare minimum for a policy then the insurer is going to have very little scope to help you when you need them, other than what is specifically stated in the insurance contract.

Now I’m not saying you should buy the most costly. I’m simply suggesting we apply the same logic as to any other purchase that we make; is it a company I’ve heard of? Can I see other customers’ reviews? What do I actually get for my money?

The larger the potential risk to you and your loved ones the more important it becomes; a poor policy covering your phone will at worse see you out of pocket by maybe £1000, but a poor choice of policy to protect your life could see your family lose their home.

The easiest solution is of course to use a professional adviser who is going to be able to recommend the correct levels of cover, explain the benefits of the chosen policy and be there if ever the plan needs to be claimed on.

Carl Summers Financial Services is an Appointed Representative of Openwork Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

Previous

Polished results

Next

It's all change at Castle House School

Check Also